A pet sitter comes to watch a cat for the first time. He finds a list of cat-sitting duties in a puddle on the counter next to a spilt glass of water. The writing on the list has blurred and is illegible. As he begins to do the tasks, The Cat follows him around leaving inky black trails. The Cat scratches him, licking the blood from his claw. Nervous and hurt, The Sitter goes to clean the litter box where he finds a bone buried. He looks up what kind of bone it is, discovering it is a human tibia.The Cat then transforms into a terrifying monster, throwing The Sitter from the couch and the phone from his hand where it hits the ground and accidentally calls The Owner. The Owner, now on speaker, say they cannot help. The Cat bites off The Sitter's hand and after a cat-and-man chase scene, The Cat swallows down The Sitter and returns to his normal cat shape.The Sitter has been transported to Hell, where he is being tortured by a group of black cats. One cat whips him, causing his shirt to rip, revealing a tattoo of a cross that reads “Only God Can Judge Me”. After a moment, The Cat retches, throwing up The Sitter and complaining to The Owner on the phone about his dissatisfaction. The Sitter slinks away and sprints to the front door where The Cat lets him leave. In the dark, The Cat demands a better sacrifice and The Owner plans to call another cat sitter.